Halliburton bribery scandal: Who are the bribe takers?
By Emmanuel Ajibulu
The Halliburton bribery tale has been a worrisome issue since it broke
in 2003, following an investigation of KBR, a Halliburton subsidiary,
over payments to a range of high profile Nigerian officials in the
executive, NNPC and the NLNG. The sum of $180 million was involved over
a contract estimated to worth about $6 billion. Kellog, Brown and Root
(KBR), the Halliburton subsidiary that got the job, was part of a
four-company joint venture on the project. The company has already
pleaded guilty and agreed to pay a fine of $520 million.
In the information available in the public domain, court documents in
the USA, KBR admitted that at the crucial junctures before the award of
the contracts, KBR's former CEO, Albert Jack Stanley and others met
with three successive former holders of a top-level office in the
executive branch of the Nigerian government to ask the office holders
to designate a representative with whom the joint-venture should
negotiate bribes to Nigerian officials. Two representatives were
accordingly hired - a consulting company, Tri-Star, based in Gribraltar
and a trading company based in Tokyo. Tri-Star was paid $132 million,
while the Tokyo Company got $50 million. All the money was to be passed
to Nigerian officials, according to documents on the website of the US
Justice Department.
The EFCC, which once probed the
$180m bribe scandal, interrogated
Edmund Daokuru, former minister of state and Funso Kupolokun, the
managing director of the NNPC. The scandal broke out after a French
court investigated KBR on an allegation that it paid $180m to FG
officials to win contracts for the construction of the NLNG plant (an
awesome project aimed at building first Africa's liquefied natural gas
plant in Bony, Rivers State, Nigeria). The House of Representatives
also carried out a separate investigation. But Halliburton officials
failed to cooperate in unveiling the Nigerian officials who shared the
$180 million bribe money, on the excuse that investigation on the same
match were afoot in the US and Europe. The bribe paid to Nigerian
officials was done at different times, starting from the General Sani
Abacha years, in 1995.
In 1995, unconfirmed report revealed that Halliburton's subsidiary,
TSKJ, hired Spanish-based Tri-Star Company, owned by indicted London
lawyer, Jeffrey Tessler, to pay $60 million in bribes to Nigerians. In
1999, $37.5 million was paid. It was not clear if the money was paid
before Abdulsalami handed over to General Obasanjo in May, 1999. But
under Obasanjo, Halliburton twice paid kickbacks– in 2001 and 2002. In
2001, $51 million was paid and in 2002, $37.5 million was paid. Two
Nigerians whose names had featured in the bribe saga were Alhaji M.D.
Yusuf and former oil minister, Dan Etete, during Abacha's
time. Yusuf
admitted collecting money from Tessler, but said it was a loan. Etete,
on his part, said the NLNG contract was awarded without his input. The
contract was valued at more than $6 billion and awarded between 1995
and 2004.
Meanwhile Former President Olusegun Obasanjo an elder statesman was
invited to BBC famous programme Hardtalk (sometime in march 2009),
anchored by Steven Suckur. In the middle of the interview Steven said
Obasanjo's name was mentioned by Tesler to have been involved in the
drama but Obasanjo distanced himself from any wrong doing. Meanwhile,
the American investigators made it known that three former Nigerian
leaders were indicted in this shoddy deal, and names like Chief
Olusegun Obasanjo, Abdusalami Abubakar and late General Sani Abacha are
not spared. Also enmeshed in the vast and formalized bribery scheme is
a long line of ministers, bureaucrats, top politicians, state and local
officials. The question now is who actually collected this bribe?
Nigerians are desperate to know. Or could it be a hoax?
However, in April 2009 some sign of relief came when the Federal
Government through the Attorney-General/Minister of Justice, Chief Mike
Aondoaka disclosed that $150 million out of the $180 million
Halliburton bribe is trapped in Zurich, Switzerland. The minister must
indeed be commended for this bold step.
His words: “We have discovered that $150million of the bribe money is
in Z
urich. That is the first shocking discovery. The entire money is
$180 million. $150 million is already in Zurich trapped.”
The Attorney-General while addressing press conference said government
was trying to find out in whose account the money was lodged. When
asked how he got to know that the money was in Zurich, he replied, “Am
I not the chief law officer of this country? I went to US and we had
useful information. For me even if you are talking to me, sharing ideas
with me I must have all the information authenticated by the government
and the US government has been very friendly to us.”
On how the government would treat those indicted, he said, “when crime
is committed we prosecute and we would not deny prosecution to
anybody.” Aondoaka said he was not happy with the way the Halliburton
story was being reported as if the government was hiding the names of
those involved.
According to him, “the judgment is under seal and you (press) are
talking as if we sealed the names in the court so you can't get the
names. “All these names you get, let me make it clear to you,
government does not prosecute out of the newspaper stories.
“If somebody said I voted $40 million for you and if the money does not
reach you, can I come and prosecute you because in his book he wrote
$40 million?
“There must be evidence that must be tendered to=2
0show that that money
was handed over to you. Is it through wire transfer? Is it through
somebody? So these are some of the things we want to establish. The
main fact that somebody wrote in his book that I have voted $40 million
that he wants to bribe you does not mean that you have taken bribe...
For instance, we have discovered that $150 million of the bribe money
is in Zurich. That is the first shocking discovery.”
Consequently, Nigerians are happy with the high powered committee set
up specifically to thoroughly investigate this matter, and Nigerians
have strong conviction that this committee which involves the EFCC boss
Hajia Farida Waziri, the Inspector General of Police Mr. Mike Okiro,
Attorney-General Chief Mike Aondoaka, others are representatives of the
National Security Adviser (NSA), the Director General of the National
Intelligence Agency (NIA) and the Director General, States Security
Services (SSS). President Umaru Yar'Adua has given assurance that his
administration will not shield any Nigerian, no matter his/her status.
The President also called for patience from Nigerians on the issue,
saying his administration is waiting for the “authentic” facts, as
currently sealed by a US Court, so those involved in the scandal would
not turn around to accuse the government of political persecution.
Meanwhile all stakeholders concerned in this investigative task should
note that there is something crucial her
e that should not be
undermined, and that is the image of Nigeria. Nigerians have read
different reports, many publication, online reports from different
websites nationally and internationally therefore the committee should
ambidextrously expedite its efforts to ensure that no stone is left
unturned; Nigerians have considered this committee as the last symbol
of hope on this alleged corrupt act. The success of this task can
conveniently be considered as a key milestone which can be instrumental
to the redemption of Nigeria's battered image over this over publicised
bribery scandal, and this can score Nigeria the point of being good
people great nation.
[email protected]
+2348023660770